51Testing软件测试网：jboss tomcat weblogic websphere 性能对比测试

jboss tomcat weblogic websphere 性能对比测试 (1)
小弟最近为几个项目选择服务器及软件，这几个项目还都不小，投入的资金各不相同但都很可观。本人一向认为性能由硬件决定，软件稳定性比性能更重要。不过，虽然小弟手里面掌控的资金绝对够用，但不能任由所谓的技术专家和销售人员摆布我的决定，所以小弟自行要对服务器硬件、软件进行测试，本文仅仅是一个开端，等以后有时间会给出一些更科学的测试结果。

测试系统环境： PC机, windows xp sp2
CPU：AMD Athlon(tm) 64 Processer 3000+ 1.80GHz
内存：1.00GB
硬盘：7200转
数据库：Mysql 5.0.17
数据库引擎：InnoDB, max connection：2000
测试工具：microsoft web application stress tool 1.1
测试模拟环境：200 users, 20 stress multiper(sockets per thread), 60 seconds

测试代码说明：

因小弟用pc测试，程序和数据库都较为简单，

mysql的表结构：
CREATE TABLE tt (
id text;
);

用来测试的jsp程序：
<%

String url="jdbc:mysql://localhost/test?user=root&password=mysql";
Class.forName("com.mysql.jdbc.Driver").newInstance();
Connection connection=DriverManager.getConnection(url);
Statement statement = connection.createStatement();
String sql="SELECT * FROM tt";
int dd = statement.executeUpdate("insert into tt values('you are my angel')");

out.println("insert::::" + dd + "<br>");
ResultSet rs = statement.executeQuery(sql);
ResultSetMetaData rmeta = rs.getMetaData();
int numColumns=rmeta.getColumnCount();
rs.next();

out.print("result:: " + rs.getString(1)+" ");
out.print("<br>");

rs.close();
statement.close();
connection.close();
%>

服务器：weblogic 9.1
测试结果：平均每秒钟响应14.71个请求，总共响应882个请求
内存占用约：335MB
tool reports:

================================================================================
================================================================================
Report name:                  12/30/2005 11:15:36 AM weblogic 250-u 20-thread
Run on:                       12/30/2005 11:15:36 AM
Run length:                   00:01:00

Web Application Stress Tool Version:1.1.293.1

Number of test clients: 1

Number of hits: 882
Requests per Second: 14.71

Socket Statistics
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Socket Connects:              902
Total Bytes Sent (in KB):     240.83
Bytes Sent Rate (in KB/s):    4.02
Total Bytes Recv (in KB):     209.48
Bytes Recv Rate (in KB/s):    3.49

Socket Errors
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect:                      0
Send:                         0
Recv:                         0
Timeouts:                     0

RDS Results
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Successful Queries: 0

Script Settings
================================================================================
Server: localhost
Number of threads: 20

Test length:                  00:01:00
Warmup:                       00:00:00
Cooldown:                     00:00:00

Use Random Delay: No

Follow Redirects: Yes
Max Redirect Depth: 15

Clients used in test
================================================================================
localhost

Clients not used in test
================================================================================
Result Codes
Code Description Count
================================================================================
200 OK 882

Page Summary
Page Hits TTFB Avg TTLB Avg Auth Query
================================================================================
GET /ttg/dbtest.jsp 882 1320.73 1321.09 No No

服务器：JBossAS-4.0.3 SP1
测试结果：平均每秒钟响应22.88个请求，总共响应1374个请求
内存占用约：165MB

tool reports:
================================================================================
================================================================================
Report name:                  12/30/2005 11:10:08 AM jboss 250-u 20-thread
Run on:                       12/30/2005 11:10:08 AM
Run length:                   00:01:00

Web Application Stress Tool Version:1.1.293.1

Number of test clients: 1

Number of hits: 1374
Requests per Second: 22.88

Socket Statistics
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Socket Connects:              1394
Total Bytes Sent (in KB):     378.45
Bytes Sent Rate (in KB/s):    6.30
Total Bytes Recv (in KB):     440.74
Bytes Recv Rate (in KB/s):    7.34

RDS Results
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Successful Queries: 0

Script Settings
================================================================================
Server: localhost
Number of threads: 20

Test length:                  00:01:00
Warmup:                       00:00:00
Cooldown:                     00:00:00

Use Random Delay: No

Follow Redirects: Yes
Max Redirect Depth: 15

Clients used in test
================================================================================
localhost

Page Summary
Page Hits TTFB Avg TTLB Avg Auth Query
================================================================================
GET /dbtest.jsp 1374 847.70 847.71 No No

服务器：apache-tomcat-5.5.12
测试结果：平均每秒钟响应14.94个请求，总共响应897个请求
内存占用约：50MB

tool reports:
================================================================================
================================================================================
Report name:                  12/30/2005 11:12:55 AM tomcat 250-u 20-thread
Run on:                       12/30/2005 11:12:55 AM
Run length:                   00:01:00

Web Application Stress Tool Version:1.1.293.1

Number of test clients: 1

Number of hits: 897
Requests per Second: 14.94

Socket Statistics
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Socket Connects:              917
Total Bytes Sent (in KB):     232.34
Bytes Sent Rate (in KB/s):    3.87
Total Bytes Recv (in KB):     197.93
Bytes Recv Rate (in KB/s):    3.30

RDS Results
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Successful Queries: 0

Script Settings
================================================================================
Server: localhost
Number of threads: 20

Test length:                  00:01:00
Warmup:                       00:00:00
Cooldown:                     00:00:00

Use Random Delay: No

Follow Redirects: Yes
Max Redirect Depth: 15

Clients used in test
================================================================================
localhost

Page Summary
Page Hits TTFB Avg TTLB Avg Auth Query
================================================================================
GET /ttg/dbtest.jsp 897 1305.27 1305.28 No No

服务器：websphere 6.0
测试结果：平均每秒钟响应23.04个请求，总共响应1384个请求
内存占用约：217MB
tool reports:
================================================================================
================================================================================
Report name:                  12/30/2005 1:50:31 PM websphere 250-u 20-thread
Run on:                       12/30/2005 1:50:31 PM
Run length:                   00:01:00

Web Application Stress Tool Version:1.1.293.1

Number of test clients: 1

Number of hits: 1384
Requests per Second: 23.04

Socket Statistics
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Socket Connects:              1403
Total Bytes Sent (in KB):     341.65
Bytes Sent Rate (in KB/s):    5.69
Total Bytes Recv (in KB):     293.80
Bytes Recv Rate (in KB/s):    4.89

RDS Results
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Successful Queries: 0

Script Settings
================================================================================
Server: localhost
Number of threads: 20

Test length:                  00:01:00
Warmup:                       00:00:00
Cooldown:                     00:00:00

Use Random Delay: No

Follow Redirects: Yes
Max Redirect Depth: 15

Clients used in test
================================================================================
localhost

Clients not used in test
================================================================================

Result Codes
Code Description Count
================================================================================
200 OK 1384

Page Summary
Page Hits TTFB Avg TTLB Avg Auth Query
================================================================================
GET /ttg/dbtest.jsp 1384 848.31 848.32 No No

结论：

呵呵，pc上面说明的问题能有多少呢？一点点吧！